Second Essay for Comment

So here's our second lottery winner. Please comment - same rules apply as for the first one. The essay is in the comment section.

First Essay for Comment

So here is the first of the winners of our own version of the lottery...Please read and comment on this essay. Feel free to pull out lines from the text where you think the writer demonstrated strong insight about the text or wrote beautifully about it. Your comments should be specific and constructive (unlike the lottery of literature, this is not to be a public stoning...). Reference the criteria in the rubric or the "How Do You Know You Wrote A Good Critical Essay" handout.

Please comment by 10/25. The essay is in the comments section, since it's much easier to read it there.